When planning a long-distance move, one of the biggest decisions is choosing between a moving broker and a moving carrier. While both options help facilitate moves, they operate differently, which can impact service quality, reliability, and overall cost. Understanding the differences can help you make the best choice for your relocation.
What Is a Moving Carrier?
A moving carrier is the company that owns and operates the trucks, employs the movers, and directly handles your belongings. When you hire a carrier, you are working directly with the team responsible for loading, transporting, and unloading your items.
How to Identify a Carrier:
- They own trucks and employ their own moving teams.
- Their USDOT number is listed as a carrier in the FMCSA database.
- They conduct in-person or virtual surveys to provide more accurate estimates.
- They are directly responsible for claims related to lost or damaged items.
Pros of Using a Carrier:
- Greater reliability: You are dealing directly with the company responsible for your move.
- More accountability: Carriers must adhere to FMCSA regulations and are responsible for your items.
- Transparent pricing: Carriers provide binding or non-binding estimates based on actual inspections, reducing unexpected costs.
- Direct communication: You can speak directly with the movers handling your items.
Cons of Using a Carrier:
- Higher cost: Carriers often charge more than brokers, as they provide direct service and maintain their own equipment and staff.
- Fewer options: Unlike brokers, carriers only offer their own services, so you may need to research multiple companies to compare prices.
What Is a Moving Broker?
A moving broker is a company that connects customers with moving carriers. Brokers act as intermediaries, meaning they do not own trucks or employ movers. Instead, they provide quotes, coordinate logistics, and arrange transportation through third-party carriers.
How to Identify a Broker:
- They do not operate their own trucks.
- Their contracts state they are not responsible for the actual transportation.
- They often provide estimates over the phone or online without an in-person inspection.
- Their U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) number is listed as a broker rather than a carrier in the FMCSA (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration) database.
Pros of Using a Broker:
- More options: Brokers can provide access to multiple carriers, potentially helping you find lower rates.
- Convenience: They handle the logistics, saving you time searching for a moving company.
Cons of Using a Broker:
- Less control: Since they don’t operate their own fleet, they cannot guarantee which company will handle your move.
- Pricing changes: The final cost may differ from the estimate if the carrier charges more than what the broker initially quoted.
- Potential delays: If a broker cannot secure a carrier in time, your move may be delayed.
Which Option Is Best for Your Move?
While brokers can provide competitive pricing and flexibility, working with a trusted carrier ensures a more reliable, transparent, and controlled moving experience. Because carriers are directly responsible for your move, they offer more accountability and consistency. The higher cost of a carrier often reflects the added security and service quality, making it a preferred choice for those prioritizing a smooth and stress-free move.
How to Verify a Moving Company
Before booking any service, always check the company’s status in the FMCSA database by searching their USDOT number. This will confirm whether they are a broker or a carrier and provide safety and complaint history. All of the companies listed on our site are verified.
By understanding the differences between brokers and carriers, you can make an informed decision that best suits your moving needs. Whether you prioritize cost savings or service reliability, choosing the right type of company ensures a smoother relocation process.
Compare top professional movers ➜
